
PORT
OF SPAIN, Trinidad, CMC – A prominent attorney has called on the
Trinidad and Tobago Government to state categorically its position on
the death penalty after a High Court judge last week ordered that the
death sentence of 52 convicted murderers should be commuted to life
imprisonment.
Senior Counsel Dana Seetahal, who is also an independent Senator here,
said that the ruling would provide “more fodder to the cynics and
critics, who say that no murderer can or will be executed in Trinidad
and Tobago”.
Attorney General Brigette Annisette-George said recently that the
Government intends to uphold the law of the land including carrying out
the death penatlty.
Last weekend, Justice Nolan Bereaux ruled that the group of 49 men and
three women be removed immediately from Death Row and instead spend the
rest of their lives in jail.
His ruling followed a constitutional motion filed by the convicted
murderers more than three years ago challenging their death sentences.
The motion covered only those persons convicted before July 7, 2004,
when the London-based Privy Council, the country’s highest court, ruled
that the sentences of everyone on Death Row at that time be commuted to
life imprisonment.
In an immediate response to the ruling, human rights lawyer and former
Attorney General Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj said blame should be placed
squarely on the Patrick Manning Government.“They should have reviewed
the death sentence, put back laws to implement the death penalty and
then follow principles of law,” said Maharaj, who served as attorney
general when the last person was executed here in 1999.
Maharaj said that the judge had “no other alternative under existing
laws”.
Seetahal, a former Magistrate, said Maharaj may have put his finger
squarely “on what must be the concern of the Government on the release
from death row of the majority of convicted murderers in the country, at
a time when the murder rate is at an all-time high”.
She noted with the number of murders likely to pass 400 this year, “one
wonders how is it that the State has delayed so long in actually
commuting the sentences of these convicts.
“It was since 2004 that the Privy Council, which still remains our
highest court, had recommended that virtually all the sentences of death
row prisoners at that time be commuted.
“It seems to me that the State should have done this since 2004 rather
than be forced to concede in a court of law to what was evident four
years ago. It may be that the authorities did not want a message being
sent that convicted murderers would not pay the price of their crime.
“If this was the reason, it made no sense, because there was no move to
execute any of them in the last four years. Further, how does it look
now at the time when the escalation of violent crime is at its worst for
the State to be ordered to take these prisoners off death row?
“Government needs to make up its mind what it intends in relation to the
death penalty and whatever it is,” she added.
Another prominent lawyer, Israel Khan said the society had to be blamed
for the situation now confronting the country.
“Society has failed, it is not the Government of the day,” he said,
reiterating an earlier call for murders to be categorised in this
country.
“Legally, you can’t fault the ruling. I am of the view, thinking about
it, is that murder at this point in time should be classified in three
degrees. First, second and third and the death penalty retained only for
first degree murder until our society has developed to such a state that
one day we would be able to abolish the death penalty,” he said in a
radio interview last week Monday.
“Without the classification in reality, the death of the death penalty
already exists,” he added.
Meanwhile, President of Crime Watch, Ian Alleyne, said while he
understood the court’s ruling, he was disappointed at the fact that the
convicted killers had escaped punishment.
“Justice Bereaux had no alternative but to make this ruling as a result
of the decision of Pratt and Morgan, the Privy Council and the local
Court of Appeal, but it is clearly a sad day for the victims and
families who were affected by the actions of this callous and heartless
group of 52 individuals,” Alleyne said.
“These people should not be spared...They broke the law, they murdered
and they should face the ultimate penalty for murder, which is death by
hanging.”
Alleyne said Government had failed to review the death penalty
legislation and related laws and so criminals had no fear of penalty for
the crimes they commit.
“Criminals will continue to terrorise, kill, murder and rape our
innocent law-abiding citizens,” Alleyne said, calling on the government
to implement the necessary legislation and deal harshly with criminals.
St. Vincent & The Grenadines-Economist Lauds Consultations In Diaspora
Caribbean- Four Caribbean Sates Eye Closer Political And Economic Union
Trinidad Government Urged To State Position On Death Penalty
But, As Usually Things Are Not Always What They Seem At First Glance
US-TERRORISM- Court Overturns Ruling In Case Of Accused In Cubana Bombing
